Weight Loss Pills for Women: Prescription, Over-the-Counter and Hidden Risks
Short answer: "weight loss pills" covers two very different things. Prescription medicines are tested, regulated and meant for specific people under a doctor's care. Over-the-counter supplements are not, and some products sold as supplements have been found to contain hidden drugs.
Prescription weight loss medicines
According to the NIDDK, these medicines supplement a healthy eating plan and regular activity; they do not replace them. They are generally considered when lifestyle changes alone are not enough, and a clinician prescribes them to adults who meet certain criteria. The NIDDK defines obesity as a BMI of 30 or greater, and says the medicines are not for everyone with a high BMI and should never be taken only to change appearance.
- Results: adults using medication plus a lifestyle program lose 3% to 12% more of their starting body weight after one year than those on lifestyle changes alone.
- Review point: if you have not lost at least 5% of your starting weight after 12 weeks on the full dose, the NIDDK says a clinician will likely advise stopping.
- Side effects: most are mild and often improve, but serious ones are rare but possible, and some past weight management drugs were removed from the U.S. market for safety reasons.
- Pregnancy: the NIDDK says never take weight management medications if you are pregnant, and avoid them if planning pregnancy.
Over-the-counter pills and supplements
The NIH Office of Dietary Supplements says these products are not a proven route to weight loss, and our review of the research is in Do Fat Burners Work?. Many rely on caffeine, and the FDA cites 400 mg a day as an amount not generally associated with negative effects in healthy adults. See Caffeine in Fat Burners to add up your own total.
The hidden-ingredient risk
The FDA has issued public notifications about weight loss products containing undeclared drugs. In its Super Slim notice, the FDA reported sibutramine, which was removed from the market in October 2010 for safety reasons and is known to substantially increase blood pressure or pulse rate in some patients, and phenolphthalein, once used in laxatives. The FDA said consumers should stop using the product immediately and throw it away, and see a health care professional if they have had side effects. (That notice dates from 2013; the FDA publishes others, so check its site for current ones.)
Red flags: claims of fast results with no effort, no clear ingredient amounts, proprietary blends, and products sold mainly on social media.
Before you take any pill
- Ask a doctor or pharmacist, especially if you take other medicines or have a health condition.
- Check the label for the amount of every active ingredient, including caffeine.
- Search the FDA's tainted-product notices for the brand name.
- Do not use a pill as a substitute for food, movement and sleep (see How to Lose Weight Fast After 40).
Our general buyer's checklist is in Weight Loss Supplements for Women Over 40.