Weight Loss Supplements for Women Over 40: What the Evidence Shows
Short answer: the evidence for weight loss supplements is weak. The U.S. National Institutes of Health's Office of Dietary Supplements (ODS) notes that little is known about whether they are effective, and says that lifestyle changes, such as a healthy diet, fewer calories and physical activity, are the basis of long-term weight loss. This guide walks through what its fact sheet says. The fact sheet covers adults in general, not women over 40 specifically, so we will say so where it matters.
Why the evidence is thin
According to the ODS fact sheet, many studies of weight loss supplements are small, short or poorly designed, and most products combine several ingredients, which makes it hard to tell what is doing what. That is the first reason to be cautious with any bottle that promises a lot.
Ingredients, according to the ODS
Little or no effect on body weight in clinical trials
- Calcium
- Chromium
- Conjugated linoleic acid (CLA)
- Guar gum
- Glucomannan
- Hoodia
Some trials suggest a possible modest effect
- African mango
- Carnitine
- Green coffee bean extract
- White kidney bean
"Possible modest effect" is not the same as "works". It means some studies saw a small change, and the studies behind it were limited.
Green tea
The ODS says brewed green tea has no reported safety concerns, but concludes that if green tea is an effective weight loss aid, any effect it has is small and not likely to be clinically relevant. Green tea extracts carry more risk: they have been linked to liver damage. We cover the trials in Does Green Tea Really Work as a Fat Burner?
Safety concerns the ODS raises
- Regulation. Supplements do not need FDA approval before they are sold. Manufacturers must ensure their products are safe and their claims truthful, and the FDA can act after a product is on the market.
- Hidden or missing information. Some labels list caffeine-containing herbs but omit the caffeine amount. Some products were found to contain little or no hoodia.
- Bitter orange. Often used in place of banned ephedra. The ODS says products may have significant safety concerns, including heart-related events.
- Garcinia cambogia. Little to no effect on weight, with reports of mania and liver toxicity.
- Yohimbe. Little research, no clear weight effect, and significant safety concerns.
- Multi-ingredient products. When liver damage or another serious problem occurs, it is often impossible to pin it on one ingredient.
For the caffeine side of this, see Caffeine in Fat Burners: How Much Is Too Much?
Tell a professional
The ODS notes that fewer than one-third of U.S. adults who use these supplements discuss them with a clinician, and says clinicians should ask especially about use in people with high blood pressure, diabetes, or heart or liver disease. A pharmacist can also check for interactions with your medications. If you are pregnant, breastfeeding or have a medical condition, ask before taking anything.
What to do first
Everything the ODS calls the basis of long-term weight loss is something you can start today: food quality, movement and sleep. Around menopause, muscle loss and changes in where fat is stored add to the picture (see Why Weight Changes After 40), and strength work helps (see our beginner plan). If you still want to try a supplement, run it through our buyer's checklist first.